Skip to main contentSkip to footer
  • Start a Custom Project
  • Call Us: (570) 724-7333
  • Visit Us in Wellsboro, PA
  • (570) 724-7333
  • Wellsboro, PA
Bethany's Jewelry logo
  • Toggle Search Menu
  • Toggle My Account Menu
    Login
    Forgot Password?

    Don’t have an account? Sign up now

  • Toggle My Wishlist
  • Toggle Shopping Cart Menu
  • Custom Design
    • Start a Project
    • Design Gallery
    • Jewelry Re-Imaginging
    • Engraving Services
    • Book a Consultation
  • Bridal
    • Build Your Engagement Ring
    • Complete Engagement RIngs
    • Engageemnt Ring Settings
    • Women's Wedding Bands
    • Men's Wedding Bands
    • Book a Consultation
  • Diamonds
    • Loose Diamonds
    • Complete Engagement Rings
    • Diamond Earrings
    • Diamond Necklaces
    • Diamond Rings
    • Diamond Bracelets
    • Diamond Trade-Up Program
    • The 4 C's of Diamonds
    • Diamond Buying Guide
  • Gemstones
    • Loose Gemstones
    • Find Your Birthsone
    • Popular Gemstones
      • Sapphire
      • Ruby
      • Emerald
      • Pearl
      • Amethyst
      • Aquamarine
      • Garnet
      • Peridot
      • Opal
      • Citrine
      • Topaz
      • Tanzanite
      • Tourmaline
      • Alexandrite
    • Gemstone Earrings
    • Gemstone Necklaces
    • Gemstone Rings
    • Gemstone Bracelets
  • Fashion Jewelry
    • Fashion Earrings
    • Fashion Necklaces
    • Fashion Rings
    • Fashion Bracelets
  • Silver Jewelry
    • Silver Earrings
    • Silver Necklaces
    • Silver Rings
    • Silver Bracelets
  • Services
    • Appraisals & Gemstone Identification
    • Bethany's VIP Program
    • Chain Repair
    • Cleaning & Inspections
    • Custom Designs
    • Engraving
    • Gold & Diamond Buying
    • Jewelry Re-Imagining
    • Pearl & Bead Restringing
    • Rhodium Plating
    • Ring Resizing
    • Shank and Head Replacement
    • Soldering
    • Watch Bands, Pins, and Link Removal
    • Watch Battery Replacement
  • The Bethany Experience
    • About Bethany
    • Bethany's VIP Experience
    • Diamond Trade-Up Program
    • Testimonials
  • Start a Custom Project
  • Call Us: (570) 724-7333
  • Visit Us in Wellsboro, PA
Log In My Cart
Bethany's Jewelry logo

Your Story, Hand-Forged
in Gold & Gemstones

You don’t need to be an artist to create a masterpiece; you just need a story. Whether you are looking to modernize a grandmother’s brooch or forge a completely new engagement ring, you are partnering directly with a GIA Graduate Gemologist.

Start a Project
A hand holding a gold engagement ring with a large stone, displayed in front of a computer showing a ring design.

Our Custom Process

The Initial Consult It all begins with a relaxed, one-on-one meeting curated for you. We work together to explore your ideas and inspirations. We can have ready diamonds or gemstones for your review. This step creates a clear, trusted design direction while balancing time, budget, and satisfaction from the start. Bethanys Jewelry Wellsboro, PA
The Initial Consult

It all begins with a relaxed, one-on-one meeting curated for you. We work together to explore your ideas and inspirations. We can have ready diamonds or gemstones for your review. This step creates a clear, trusted design direction while balancing time, budget, and satisfaction from the start.

CAD MODELING & Wax Next, your design is brought to life through 3D CAD rendering and or resin model you can hold and try on. This allows you to see proportions, feel the piece, and request any adjustments before production begins. We take the time to refine every detail, ensuring you feel confident and excited before moving forward. Bethanys Jewelry Wellsboro, PA
CAD MODELING & Wax

Next, your design is brought to life through 3D CAD rendering and or resin model you can hold and try on. This allows you to see proportions, feel the piece, and request any adjustments before production begins. We take the time to refine every detail, ensuring you feel confident and excited before moving forward.

Production & Delivery Once approved, your piece enters production. Skilled craftsmanship and careful quality control guide every step of the process. Final production and finishing typically take 2–3 weeks, after which your custom jewelry is ready to be picked up and enjoyed. Beautifully made and designed to last a lifetime. Bethanys Jewelry Wellsboro, PA
Production & Delivery

Once approved, your piece enters production. Skilled craftsmanship and careful quality control guide every step of the process. Final production and finishing typically take 2–3 weeks, after which your custom jewelry is ready to be picked up and enjoyed. Beautifully made and designed to last a lifetime.

Start a Project

From Imagination
to Reality

You do not need to be an artist; you just need a vision. We combine GIA gemological expertise with advanced 3D technology to build your unique piece from the ground up. We guide you through the "physics of sparkle," ensuring your custom design is not only breathtakingly beautiful but structurally sound for everyday wear.

Start a Project
Elegant gold engagement ring featuring a large rectangular diamond and smaller accent stones on the band.
Bethanys Jewelry Wellsboro, PA

Honor the Past,
Wear the Future

Do not let your family heirlooms sit in a dark drawer. We specialize in transforming outdated jewelry into modern treasures while keeping the sentiment alive. Whether it is laser-engraving a special date or melting down gold to cast a completely new ring, we preserve your legacy while refreshing the style.

Make an Appointment

Let's Start Your
Journey Today!

We invite you to book a complimentary consultation to discuss your ideas. This is a pressure-free experience where we sketch concepts, look at loose stones, and discuss your budget. We can even provide an instant quote for BriteCo insurance, ensuring your future masterpiece is protected before it is even made.

Make an AppointmentLearn About BriteCo.
Sketch of a blue gemstone with diamond accents, signed by the designer.
Our Hours
Monday:
Closed
Tue-Sat:Tuesday - Saturday:
10:00am - 5:00pm
Sunday:
Closed
Our Address
84 Main St
Wellsboro, PA 16901
(570) 724-7333
Store Information
Our Jewelry
  • Proposal-Ready Rings
  • Engagement Ring Builder
  • Women's Wedding Bands
  • Men's Wedding Bands
  • Gemstone Jewelry
  • Diamond Jewelry
  • Silver Jewelry
  • Diamond Studs
  • Earrings
  • Necklaces
  • Rings
  • Bracelets
Our Services
  • Cleaning & Inspections
  • Ring Resizing
  • Watch Battery Replacement
  • Chain Repair
  • Soldering
  • Custom Designs
  • Gold Buying
  • Rhodium Plating
  • Shank and Head Replacement
  • Watch Bands, Pins, and Link Removal
  • Pearl & Bead Restringing
  • Appraisals & Gemstone Identification
  • Engraving
  • Jewelry Re-Imagining
Our Store
  • About Bethany's
  • Bethany's VIP Experience
  • Diamond Trade-Up Program
  • Testimonials
  • Make an Appointment
  • Return Policy
Become a Member

Join for free and discover exclusive access to our biggest drops, promotions, members-only products, and more.

Join Now for Free
Follow Us
  • Visit the authorizenet website
  • Visit the gia website
  • Brite Co. Jewelry Insurance Partner
  • Visit the joa website
  • Wellsboro Chamber of Commerce
  • Visit the rjo website
  • Return Policy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Accessibility Statement

© 2026 Bethany's Jewelry. All Rights Reserved.

Powered by: Punchmark

My Bag
Shopping cart contents
Loading

Learn how we use cookies in our Privacy Policy or manage cookie preferences.