Skip to main contentSkip to footer
  • Start a Custom Project
  • Call Us: (570) 724-7333
  • Visit Us in Wellsboro, PA
  • (570) 724-7333
  • Wellsboro, PA
Bethany's Jewelry logo
  • Toggle Search Menu
  • Toggle My Account Menu
    Login
    Forgot Password?

    Don’t have an account? Sign up now

  • Toggle My Wishlist
  • Toggle Shopping Cart Menu
  • Custom Design
    • Start a Project
    • Design Gallery
    • Jewelry Re-Imaginging
    • Engraving Services
    • Book a Consultation
  • Bridal
    • Build Your Engagement Ring
    • Complete Engagement RIngs
    • Engageemnt Ring Settings
    • Women's Wedding Bands
    • Men's Wedding Bands
    • Book a Consultation
  • Diamonds
    • Loose Diamonds
    • Complete Engagement Rings
    • Diamond Earrings
    • Diamond Necklaces
    • Diamond Rings
    • Diamond Bracelets
    • Diamond Trade-Up Program
    • The 4 C's of Diamonds
    • Diamond Buying Guide
  • Gemstones
    • Loose Gemstones
    • Find Your Birthsone
    • Popular Gemstones
      • Sapphire
      • Ruby
      • Emerald
      • Pearl
      • Amethyst
      • Aquamarine
      • Garnet
      • Peridot
      • Opal
      • Citrine
      • Topaz
      • Tanzanite
      • Tourmaline
      • Alexandrite
    • Gemstone Earrings
    • Gemstone Necklaces
    • Gemstone Rings
    • Gemstone Bracelets
  • Fashion Jewelry
    • Fashion Earrings
    • Fashion Necklaces
    • Fashion Rings
    • Fashion Bracelets
  • Silver Jewelry
    • Silver Earrings
    • Silver Necklaces
    • Silver Rings
    • Silver Bracelets
  • Services
    • Appraisals & Gemstone Identification
    • Bethany's VIP Program
    • Chain Repair
    • Cleaning & Inspections
    • Custom Designs
    • Engraving
    • Gold & Diamond Buying
    • Jewelry Re-Imagining
    • Pearl & Bead Restringing
    • Rhodium Plating
    • Ring Resizing
    • Shank and Head Replacement
    • Soldering
    • Watch Bands, Pins, and Link Removal
    • Watch Battery Replacement
  • The Bethany Experience
    • About Bethany
    • Bethany's VIP Experience
    • Diamond Trade-Up Program
    • Testimonials
  • Start a Custom Project
  • Call Us: (570) 724-7333
  • Visit Us in Wellsboro, PA
Log In My Cart
Bethany's Jewelry logo
Your browser does not support the video tag.

Make the Moment
Sparkle &Shine

An engagement ring is more than a purchase; it is a promise. Don't trust your most important question to a cold screen. At Bethany’s, you partner directly with a GIA Graduate Gemologist to find a diamond that captivates the room.

Shop All Rings

Loose Diamond Search

Round Princess Emerald Asscher Radiant
Oval Marquise Pear Cushion Heart
Couple embracing, showcasing an elegant engagement ring on the woman's hand.

Create a ring
online

Start Your JourneyLearn About Settings

Bridal Categories

Browse engagement rings and wedding bands curated for a lifetime of love.

Elegant gold engagement ring featuring a rectangular diamond centerpiece.

Complete Engagement Rings

Gold engagement ring setting with silver prongs. Visit Bethany's Jewelry in Wellsboro for more details.

Engagement Ring Settings

Gold wedding band with sparkling diamonds, perfect for engagements or special occasions. Visit Bethany's Jewelry in Wellsboro.

Women's Wedding Bands

Polished silver men's wedding band displayed on a white background. Visit Bethany's Jewelry for more details.

Men's Wedding Bands

Something New, Something You!

Your love story doesn't belong in a mold, so why should your ring? Whether you are dreaming of a completely fresh design or want to incorporate the soul of a family heirloom, we bridge the gap between sentiment and science. Partner directly with a Graduate Gemologist to forge a symbol of your love that is structurally sound, visually breathtaking, and entirely yours .

Start From ScratchRe-Imagine Old Jewelry
Detailed sketch of intricate jewelry designs with a pen in focus, showcasing artistry in jewelry creation.
Three sparkling diamonds in different cuts displayed on a soft fabric background at Bethany's Jewelry in Wellsboro.

Meet with our custom jewelry experts

There is no substitute for seeing a diamond’s true performance with your own eyes. Schedule a relaxed, no-pressure consultation to view loose stones under the microscope with a GIA Graduate Gemologist .

Make an Appointment
Our Hours
Monday:
Closed
Tue-Sat:Tuesday - Saturday:
10:00am - 5:00pm
Sunday:
Closed
Our Address
84 Main St
Wellsboro, PA 16901
(570) 724-7333
Store Information
Our Jewelry
  • Proposal-Ready Rings
  • Engagement Ring Builder
  • Women's Wedding Bands
  • Men's Wedding Bands
  • Gemstone Jewelry
  • Diamond Jewelry
  • Silver Jewelry
  • Diamond Studs
  • Earrings
  • Necklaces
  • Rings
  • Bracelets
Our Services
  • Cleaning & Inspections
  • Ring Resizing
  • Watch Battery Replacement
  • Chain Repair
  • Soldering
  • Custom Designs
  • Gold Buying
  • Rhodium Plating
  • Shank and Head Replacement
  • Watch Bands, Pins, and Link Removal
  • Pearl & Bead Restringing
  • Appraisals & Gemstone Identification
  • Engraving
  • Jewelry Re-Imagining
Our Store
  • About Bethany's
  • Bethany's VIP Experience
  • Diamond Trade-Up Program
  • Testimonials
  • Make an Appointment
  • Return Policy
Become a Member

Join for free and discover exclusive access to our biggest drops, promotions, members-only products, and more.

Join Now for Free
Follow Us
  • Visit the authorizenet website
  • Visit the gia website
  • Brite Co. Jewelry Insurance Partner
  • Visit the joa website
  • Wellsboro Chamber of Commerce
  • Visit the rjo website
  • Return Policy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Accessibility Statement

© 2026 Bethany's Jewelry. All Rights Reserved.

Powered by: Punchmark

My Bag
Shopping cart contents
Loading

Learn how we use cookies in our Privacy Policy or manage cookie preferences.